We’re reader supported. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission at no extra cost to you!

ComparisonLast updated on 23 January 2025

Tuft and Needle Original vs Casper Element Pro vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm

Easily compare the Casper Element Pro vs Tuft and Needle Original Mattresses side-by-side.

Tuft & Needle Original mattress on Mattress Zone Canada
Casper Element mattress on Mattress Zone Canada
Brooklyn Bedding Plank mattress on Mattress Zone Canada
Latest Promotions
No promotion available

Casper Birthday Sale - Up to 25% off mattresses, 30% off bundles. Offer expires 4/23/25

See Casper website

Big Spring Refresh Sale - 25% Off Sitewide. Use Promo Code : SPRING25.

See Brooklyn Bedding website

At a glance

Recommended For
N/A
N/A
The Brooklyn Bedding Plank mattress is ideal for individuals who prefer a highly supportive sleeping surface and require a firm mattress to alleviate back pain or provide proper spinal alignment. Its customizable comfort levels make it a versatile option for a range of sleepers who want the option to adjust their sleeping surface as needed. It is also a good choice for couples or those who share a bed with a restless sleeper, as its excellent motion isolation capabilities ensure a peaceful and undisturbed sleep. Additionally, its durable construction makes it a good investment for those looking for a long-lasting and supportive mattress. Overall, the Plank mattress is ideal for those who prioritize support and firmness over plushness and softness, and who are looking for a high-quality and durable mattress at an affordable price point.
What we like
N/A
N/A
1. Unmatched Firmness: The Brooklyn Bedding Plank mattress is designed to provide the firmest sleeping surface on the market, making it an ideal option for those who prefer a highly supportive feel. Its unique construction eliminates the need for a traditional box spring, providing a more stable and supportive foundation. 2. Customizable Comfort: The Plank mattress offers a unique flippable design, with one side being ultra-firm and the other side being firm. This allows sleepers to customize their comfort level to their individual preferences and needs, making it a versatile option for a range of sleepers. 3. Durable Construction: The Plank mattress is made with high-quality materials that are designed to last. Its solid construction eliminates the need for frequent flipping or rotating, ensuring that it will maintain its shape and support for years to come. 4. Excellent Motion Isolation: The Plank mattress's design includes multiple layers of foam and support materials that absorb and isolate motion, making it an excellent choice for couples or those who share a bed with a restless sleeper. 5. Affordable Price: Despite its high-quality materials and advanced design features, the Plank mattress is priced affordably, making it an excellent value for those looking for a supportive and durable mattress without breaking the bank.
Keep in Mind
N/A
N/A
1. Limited Comfort Options: While the Plank mattress's ultra-firm and firm options may be ideal for those who prefer a highly supportive sleeping surface, it may not be the best fit for those who prefer a softer, more plush feel. The lack of options in terms of comfort levels may limit its appeal to a certain segment of sleepers. 2. Heavy and Difficult to Move: Due to its solid construction and high-density materials, the Plank mattress can be quite heavy and difficult to move, especially for those who live alone or have limited physical mobility. This may be a consideration for those who need to move their mattress frequently or who plan on relocating in the near future.

Essential Mattress Info

Brand
Tuft & Needle (Canada)Casper (Canada)Brooklyn Bedding (Canada)
About
Mattress Type
All FoamAll FoamAll Foam
Prices
Video
Certifications
CertiPur-US®
CertiPur-US®CertiPur-US®CertiPur-US®
GREENGUARD Gold
GREENGUARD Gold✕✕

Trial & Warranty

Trial Period
✓✓✓
Trial Period (nights)
100100120
Warranty Length (years)
101010

Firmness Options

One Firmness Fits All?
✓✓✕
Adjustable Firmness
✕✕✓
Half-Half Firmness
✕✕✕
Selectable Firmness
✕✕✕
Flippable / Reversible Firmness
✕✕✓
Firmness Info
The Tuft & Needle Original mattress is medium-firm in feel. It was designed to be universally comfortable and moderately firm, in order to benefit all different types of sleepers regardless of factors such as age, height, weight, or the way you sleep. If the mattress isn't meeting your expectations, simply reach out to Tuft & Needle to initiate a hassle-free return.
When we designed the Casper Element, we knew we had to deliver lasting comfort at an unbeatable price. It borrows elements from our signature mattress to promise coolness and support in a more cost-efficient design.
Our dual comfort design offers two variations: the top side of the mattress is firm; the bottom side is ultra-firm, allowing for an easily flippable, highly customizable sleep.

Mattress Construction

Materials Overview
The Tuft & Needle Original is a 2-layer mattress:
  • 3" T&N Adaptive foam
  • 6.5" polyurethane base foam.
We made an expensive mattress that's not expensive. The sweet spot between superior comfort and serious value. It's a premium mattress in a streamlined design. 2 layers of polyurethane foam:
  • Breathable AirScape™ Top Foam
  • Durable Support Foam.
Inspired by the minimalist approach to sleep in the Far East, the Plank is the firmest, flattest, healthiest way to sleep. It has 4 layers of construction:
  • 0.75" Quilted Top
  • 2" TitanFlex™ Foam
  • 7" High-Density Base Foam
  • 1.5" Quilted Bottom.
Comfort Info
The heat-wicking graphite and cooling gel in the T&N Adaptive® foam work together to help keep you cool while you sleep. This mattress is designed to pull your body heat away while remaining cozy and comfy.
Cooling helps keep you at the right temperature for your best rest. We also own the manufacturing process, so we can guarantee all Casper mattresses meet our high standards for comfort. Plus every mattress saves up to 9 recycled bottles from the environment.
Engineered to reduce pressure on your circulatory system the Plank provides for better blood flow - and better lower back support, compelling you to inhale more oxygen while you snooze.
Support Info
T&N Adaptive® foam, which is unique to Tuft & Needle, provides great pressure relief and support and is comfortable for all sleep styles.
The durable base is engineered to prevent sinking and sagging while supporting your whole body.
The Plank offers a firmer, flatter, flippable surface for a neutral spine position that's better for your back and posture overall.
Comfort Specs
The addition of heat-absorbing graphite is designed to conduct heat through the bed, away from you.
Cooling gel beads help wick away heat. When you lay down, the cooling beads create additional support for optimal comfort.
Long-lasting, open-cell foam creates a breathable foundation.
A top layer of proprietary perforated breathable foam helps reduce heat, the tiny holes move hot air and body heat away. This innovative cooling system is designed to help keep you cool all night.
N/A
Support Specs
T&N Adaptive® Foam was invented by T&N alongside top American chemists, this foam is durable, breathable, and the perfect balance of flexible support. Engineered based on customer feedback, it provides pressure relief where you need it most.
Premium AirScape™ foam conforms to your body to relieve pressure.
A 2" layer of our firmest transitional TitanFlex™ foam adds deep compression support.
A 7" high density base foam ensures durability and stability for the life of your bed.
Fabric Specs
The Tuft & Needle mattress cover is made with a blend of micro polyamide and polyester. It has a soft and plush feel. Micro polyamide is breathable and durable. It keeps you cool and dries up to 8 times faster than cotton. The mattress cover is resistant to pilling and tearing. The Original mattress cover is not waterproof or removable/washable, so if there are any concerns, we'd recommend using a mattress protector.
N/A
The flippable design of the Plank allows you to choose your ideal firmness level: a .75" quilted top layer, patterned with continuous stitching, ensures zero loft for an ultra-firm sleep experience - or, flip the mattress, and a 1.5" quilted layer, patterned with tack-and-jump stitching, creates minimal loft for a firm sleep experience.
Manufactured in
CanadaUndisclosedUnited States

Suitability

Side Sleepers
✓✓✓
Back Sleepers
✓✓✓

Size & Weight

Twin
✓✓✓
Twin Dimensions
75 x 39 x 10 "74.5 x 37.5 x 10 "75 x 38 x 11 "
Twin Weight (lb)
5043
Twin XL
✓✕✓
Twin XL Dimensions
80 x 39 x 10 "✕80 x 38 x 11 "
Twin XL Weight (lb)
52✕
Full
✓✓✓
Full Dimensions
75 x 54 x 10 "74.5 x 52.5 x 10 "75 x 53 x 11 "
Full Weight (lb)
6357
Queen
✓✓✓
Queen Dimensions
80 x 60 x 10 "79.5 x 59.5 x 10 "80 x 60 x 11 "
Queen Weight (lb)
7269
King
✓✓✓
King Dimensions
80 x 76 x 10 "79.5 x 75.5 x 10 "80 x 76 x 11 "
King Weight (lb)
9488
Cal King
✕✕✓
Cal King Dimensions
✕✕84 x 72 x 11 "
Cal King Weight (lb)
✕✕

Delivery

Delivery Cost
FREEFREEYES
Delivery Info
All products include free shipping (additional fees may apply in remote postal codes). Mattresses are sent directly to your doorstep compressed, vacuum-sealed, and packed in a conveniently-sized box. Typically shipped within 1 to 7 business days.
We ship via UPS Standard in the United States and Canada from warehouse partners in each country. Additional fees may apply for Northwest Territories, Yukon, and Nunavut. Terms and conditions apply.
Shipping to Canada is done via UPS. For Canadian orders, it can take 3-5 business days after processing. All taxes and duties are included. Shipping calculated at checkout.
Prices
Latest Promotions
No promotion available

Casper Birthday Sale - Up to 25% off mattresses, 30% off bundles. Offer expires 4/23/25

See Casper website

Big Spring Refresh Sale - 25% Off Sitewide. Use Promo Code : SPRING25.

See Brooklyn Bedding website